Analytic philosophy can be distinguished from literary criticism via syntax alone

Analytic philosophy can be distinguished from literary criticism with 90-95% accuracy via syntax alone. Moreover, a classifier trained to separate them in early C20 does better predicting future separations than a C21 one predicts past ones, suggesting philosophy syntax narrows/specializes in ~C21.

A four-panel figure showing the probability of predicting articles from The Journal of Philosophy versus PMLA using quarter-century models. Each panel represents a different training period (1925-1950, 1950-1975, 1975-2000, 2000-2025). Gray shaded regions indicate training periods. The model trained on early C21 philosophy vs literature cannot accurately distinguish early C20 philosophy vs literature, but the reverse is not true.

Hierarchical cluster of syntactic features predicting philosophy (blue) vs criticism (red).

Top 2 distinctive features for Philosophy vs Criticism.

An example of the importance of the "marker" feature in philosophy.

Originally posted on Bluesky.

← All notes