Creative Collapse: a new AHRC/SSHRC project on AI-driven homogenisation of language

Embargo lifted! AHRC/SSHRC is funding our grant, “Creative Collapse”, on AI-driven homogenisation of language across genres. The team: Florian Carichon, Golnoosh Farnadi, Nathaniel Barr, Laurent Dubreuil, Maria Antoniak, Fernando Diaz, Mirco Musolesi, & me.

The project is bi-disciplinary, tri-national, septa-institutional, and an octopus of brilliant humans. HQ is Cambridge Digital Humanities.

Here is an evocative yet inscrutable image.

The formal range of impressionism and expressionism is funnelled into a narrower range in its AI reproduction.

About the project

What is ‘slop’? The word has surged into public discourse as a vehicle for distaste with AI-generated cultural output: stories with predictable arcs, verse with sing-song rhymes, prose with an eager-to-please neutrality.

Creative Collapse is an 18-month tri-national collaboration asking which dimensions of AI-driven cultural homogenisation are computationally tractable to intervene on, and which are too deeply entrenched. A specific finding orients the project: instruction-tuned models rhyme at roughly six times the rate of their base-model equivalents on identical poem completions, locating the site of homogenisation in the post-training alignment pipeline rather than in the training data. AI homogeneity appears, in substantial part, to be a side effect of aligning models for ‘helpfulness’. Existing intervention work has been evaluated almost exclusively against genre-agnostic embedding-distance metrics that cannot tell us whether interventions have actually recovered the formal variation a humanist would recognise as the substance of a genre. We address this gap across three contrasting genres spanning the creative–functional spectrum: sonnets, short-form digital storytelling, and academic abstracts. The resulting humanities-informed metrics serve as evaluation criteria for intervention experiments using prompt redesign, fine-tuning, and decoding-level methods. By March 2028 the project will release an open-source Python toolkit and benchmark suite, documented intervention recipes for AI developers, and joint publications synthesising the cross-genre findings.

Team: Ryan Heuser (Cambridge, project lead); Mirco Musolesi (UCL, UK co-lead); Laurent Dubreuil (Cornell); Fernando Diaz (Carnegie Mellon); Florian Carichon and Golnoosh Farnadi (McGill); Nathaniel Barr (Sheridan College); Maria Antoniak (Colorado Boulder).

Funding: UKRI (AHRC) and SSHRC, through the Canada–UK–US AI humanities sandpit, part of Doing AI Differently (Alan Turing Institute / University of Edinburgh). October 2026 – March 2028.

Part of Creative Collapse.

Originally posted on Bluesky.

← All notes