Historical Semantics

The centrality of the countable, modelable unit of the word in distant reading connects its mode of historiography to that of the lexicographers of intellectual history, like Raymond Williams or Reinhart Koselleck, via their units of Keyword or Grundbegriff (fundamental concept). It’s no coincidence that both our digital and Williams’ and Koselleck’s analog histories gravitate around the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries, placing many words’ key semantic turning-points there, due to shared linguistic conditions of abstraction and collectivization arising in that revolutionary period. Koselleck named this period the Sattelzeit, a “hinge period” of a systemic conceptual transformation into modernity. With digital corpora and computational semantics, we can test hypotheses such as these by locating where semantic turning-points in words took place.

In progress: The Great Vector of Being

What does Arthur Lovejoy’s history of ideas look like when its unit, the “unit-idea,” is rebuilt computationally? Taking the Great Chain of Being as a test case, this project compares several units of analysis from intellectual history and digital humanities (word counts, LLM-annotated passages, and semantic directions in word-embedding models), applying them to Lovejoy’s own quotations and to four centuries of English print, 1600–2000. It extends Computing Koselleck’s account of the Sattelzeit as a turn toward abstraction, asking whether the Chain’s vertical order, from matter to spirit and from particular to universal, survives as a direction in the vocabulary itself.

Notes

Testing the Sattelzeit hypothesis

Lastly, I use this method to test the Sattelzeit hypothesis. Did an unsual number of words really undergo their most significant changes during 1770-1830? It turns out: yes—but, we find not 1 but 2 Sattelzeiten, 1 in that period & 1 in early C20. I conclude by hazarding some initial interpretations.

Graph showing that words, across parts of speech, are most likely to pivot in meaning in the early C19 or the early C20.

Continue →

Ultrasounds of semantic change

This is done by analyzing these “ultrasounds of semantic change.” These are just distance matrices, showing the relative difference in the usage contexts for a word across every pair of historical periods. The big white squares indicate periods of self-similarity; between them, periods of change.

The lighter a cell, the closer the word's contexts for the period on the x-axis are to the word's contexts for the period on the y-axis. The larger white blocks indicate periods of stability; between them, periods of change.

Originally posted on Bluesky.

Identifying pivot-points in semantic changes of keywords

I adapt a method from @tedunderwood.me, & “The Evolution of Popular Music” (Mauch et al), to measure “novelty” over time. I use it to pinpoint when a word’s frequent contexts significantly pivot away from past ones. “Station”, e.g., pivots sharply in 1850s from a word for class, to a train station.

Continue →

Tracing types of semantic change

Feels strange to post about work stuff, but in my self-quarantine I’m working on more historical semantics for cambridgekeydata.org: trying to characterize the types of semantic change undergone by certain keywords across the 19th and 20th centuries.

Originally posted on Twitter.

Computational Keywords

Computational Keywords, or Modern Abstractions: Using computational semantics to find which abstract nouns changed the most in meaning during the transition into modernity. (= DH work I’m doing now in my dissertation on abstraction in 18th-century literature.)

Originally posted on Twitter.

Transformation of ‘labour’

Raymond Williams: “From C17.. labour.. lost its.. association with pain” & became “a general social activity.. a term in political economy”

Originally posted on Twitter.

← All projects